Whether you're heading out for a day of hunting or you're planning to spend several days backcountry camping, you'll need a heavy duty cooler capable of keeping ice frozen for more than just a couple of hours. There are lots of coolers to choose from, some of which are pricey and loaded with far more amenities than most outdoor enthusiasts need. Coleman has a line of Xtreme Coolers that balances affordability with high performance. Our Coleman Xtreme Cooler review looks at how this practical line of coolers stacks up against some other options.
No products found.
What Is the Coleman Xtreme Cooler?
Coleman's line of Xtreme Coolers represents a step up from the company's conventional ice chest coolers. The extra insulation in these coolers allows them to keep ice frozen for days at a time, making them ideal for extended camping trips and weekend adventures. Coleman's Xtreme Coolers are available in 28, 52, 62, 70, 100, and 120-quart capacities. The 68-quart version, which is equipped with wheels and a tow handle, is one of the more popular options.
Coleman's line of Xtreme Coolers are classic coolers with a straightforward design. These coolers don't have a lot of bells and whistles, but they're solid performers when it comes to chilling foods and beverages for extended periods of time. They're also easy to use.
What Materials Are These Coolers Constructed Out of?
All of the Xtreme coolers that were part of our Coleman Xtreme Cooler Review are made out of heavy plastic. Some users reported problems with the plastic handles and hinges on Coleman coolers breaking off. All of the Xtreme coolers are hard-sided coolers. In general, hard-sided coolers are more durable that soft-sided options and are capable of keeping ice frozen for longer periods of time.
How Easy Is It to Remove Melted Ice and Leftover Water From These Coolers?
The smaller Xtreme coolers can simply be turned over to allow the water to drain out. Our Coleman Xtreme Cooler Review found that many of the larger coolers have leak-resistant drains that allow users to easily let the water out without going to the trouble of turning the cooler upside down. Coleman Xtreme coolers are also easy to clean. A damp cloth will usually do the trick.
Are Xtreme Coolers Good for Boating?
In conjunction with its Xtreme cooler line, Coleman also has a line of Xtreme coolers that are specially designed for marine uses and settings. Our Coleman Xtreme Cooler Review found that the company's marine coolers tend to be larger because of the extra capacity marine coolers usually require. The Xtreme marine coolers, like the mainstream Xtreme coolers, have extra insulation that keeps ice frozen for long periods of time.
How Will I Know Which Cooler Size Is Best for Me?
Our Coleman Xtreme Cooler review found that the 70-quart size is often the most family-friendly size. For smaller groups, or for just a couple of hours of tailgating, the 28-quart Xtreme cooler should be sufficient. Remember that the larger the cooler is, the heavier it will be when filled to capacity.
Even though Coleman Xtreme Coolers are pricier than the company's conventional ice chests, they are still considered a budget option. Most Coleman Xtreme coolers are priced between $50 and $100, making them a steal compared to higher-end coolers manufactured by other companies that can cost more than $200. Our Coleman Xtreme cooler review found that Xtreme coolers are widely available. They can be purchased at sporting goods stores, mass market retailers, and from online marketplaces like Amazon.
How It Compares
We picked a few similar products available on the market to see how they compare.
No products found.
Our Coleman Xtreme Cooler Review found that these coolers are a durable option. Although some features on these coolers may wear out over time, this line is designed to last for at least several years under normal conditions.
Coleman's line of Xtreme Coolers have extra-thick 1.5-inch insulating walls and insulated lids. The company says its larger Xtreme coolers can keep ice intact for as long as 6 days. On hot days when the temperature is over 90 degrees Fahrenheit, some users have found that Coleman's Xtreme coolers don't keep ice for quite as long as advertised. However, the Xtreme line is still able to keep ice longer than Coleman's regular line of coolers. This cooler is easy to clean.
All Coleman Xtreme Coolers have side or top plastic handles that are comfortable and easy to use. Some of the larger Xtreme coolers are outfitted with handles for towing and grooved wheels. Although the wheels don't have as much traction as those found on more expensive coolers, they still contribute to the overall portability of Coleman's Xtreme line. Xtreme coolers that have wheels tend to have a little less interior storage space.
All of the coolers in Coleman's Xtreme line come with 4 built-in cup holders. The only exception is the 28-quart Xtreme cooler, which has just 2 cup holders because of its smaller size. The sturdy lids on this line of coolers can double as seating with a capacity of up to 250 pounds. In a pinch, the lids can also be used as a stepstool. Xtreme coolers are available in at least 7 different colors.
No products found.
Like Coleman's Xtreme Coolers, the Igloo MaxCold is a classic ice chest-style cooler with insulation that is heavy enough to keep ice frozen for days. This is a hard-shell cooler that is capable of holding up to 114 12-ounce beverage cans. The Igloo MaxCold, which measures 16 inches high, 16.5 inches wide, and nearly 30 inches long, is also equipped with a stain and odor-resistant liner. Weighing in at about 12 pounds when empty, this cooler is well-suited for extended camping and fishing trips and other outdoor adventures. It comes with a one-year warranty.
The Igloo MaxCold is made entirely out of plastic, and some users have complained that the plastic hinges wear out over time. However, the overall quality of this cooler is in line with other low-cost coolers. The cooler is also durable enough to be carried on a truck bed or loaded onto a boat.
The MaxCold cooler has Igloo's Ultratherm insulation, which the company says will keep ice intact for up to 5 days. Extremely high temperatures and frequently opening and closing the cooler lid may erode the length of time ice will remain intact, but the Igloo MaxCol still represents a good option for extended refrigeration. This cooler is also easy to clean with a damp cloth.
The Igloo MaxCold 70-quart cooler has reinforced plastic swing-up handles on either end and a tie-down loop for versatile carrying and loading. There is also a model that comes with wheels.
Igloo's MaxCold Cooler has a hinged lid that is easy to operate but does not incorporate any built-in cup holders. Like the Coleman Xtreme coolers, the lid of this cooler can double as a seat. A unique design feature on this cooler is its drainage port, which allows a drainage hose to be hooked on to channel wastewater away from the cooler. This feature is ideal for boaters, who can use this setup to channel wastewater over the side of the vessel.
No products found.
Built NY's Large Freezer Welded Cooler is a soft-sided cooler capable of carrying up to 18 beverage cans and 10 pounds of ice. The wide mouth and roll-top design of this cooler makes it easy to load, unload, and clean. The shell of this Built NY cooler is made from tough puncture-resistant fabric similar to what is used to construct white water rafts. This olive-colored cooler is collapsible and can be tucked into a large suitcase when not in case, making it an ideal option for travel or road trips. It comes with a limited lifetime warranty.
Don't let the bag-like design of this cooler fool you. The Built NY cooler is durably constructed out of a tough fabric capable of resisting punctures and abrasions. This is a rugged cooler that can be tossed onto truck beds or carried on rigorous hikes.
Built NY's cooler will keep ice frozen for several hours at most, meaning this cooler is better-suited for shorter excursions or day hikes. But even if your ice melts, the welded seams on this bag prevent leaking. This bag has insulated sides that are one-inch thick and an insulated bottom that is 1.5-inches deep. The liner of this cooler is BPA-free and safe for food.
The comfortable shoulder strap on this cooler makes it easy to tote this bag when it is filled to its 30-pound capacity. This bag is ideal for taking smaller amounts of food and drink on shorter excursions. To open this bag, simply unclip the side and top latches, unroll the top, and unzip the bag.
The wide mouth of Built NY's cooler makes it easy to pack, unpack, and clean this cooler. The wide mouth can also serve another purpose; simply leave the mouth open and use the entire cooler as a party bucket. The collapsible design of this cooler makes it very versatile, but some users complained that the zipper is not leakproof.
No products found.
The RTIC 65 cooler is an almost indestructible piece of outdoor equipment that is designed for rugged use and capable of keeping ice frozen for 10 days. This cooler is even bear resistant. The RTIC 65 can carry up to 65 cans or 70 pounds of ice. The RTIC measures 32 by 17 by 18 inches on the outside and weighs just over 36 pounds. The cooler has 2 drainage ports for quick draining and easy cleaning. It comes with a 7-year warranty.
This is a roto-molded cooler, meaning it has a continuous thick plastic wall that is very strong. This cooler is perfect for long hunting and camping trips in rugged conditions. It's difficult to damage this heavy-duty cooler.
Capable of keeping ice frozen for up to 10 days, the RTIC 65 is one of the highest-performing coolers on the market. All of that refrigeration capacity comes at the cost of some interior space. Because of the insulation it is packed with, this cooler's 65-quart capacity is smaller than what you would expect for a cooler of this size. The walls of this cooler are 3 inches thick to accommodate all of the extra insulation.
The RTIC 65 has rope handles with a plastic tube for gripping. The cooler also has two rubber latches for holding the lid closed. The portability of this cooler, however, is limited by the fact that it weights 36 pounds when empty. This cooler is big and heavy, making it less portable than some other options.
The RTIC 65 has a lid that can double as a seat, a step stool, a tabletop, or even extra cutting board. This cooler is designed to include molded tie-down slots, a no-sweat exterior, and non-slip feet.
Coleman Xtreme Cooler Review: Conclusion
Although there are fancier, pricier, and more amenity-laden coolers on the market, our Coleman Xtreme Cooler Review found that this line has a number of positive features. Coleman Xtreme coolers are durable, easy to use, and they have insulating capabilities that go above and beyond what conventional Coleman coolers can offer.
They're also available in a full range of colors and sizes. Coleman's Xtreme coolers will easily meet the needs of most outdoor enthusiasts, and they won't break the bank. Although our Coleman Xtreme Cooler review found that these coolers don't always last as long as higher-end options, the slightly shorter lifespan of these coolers is offset by their affordability.
Featured image source: Pexels